
In a letter dated August 17, Roshan placed his formal objections before the Cantonment Board under Section 258 of the Cantonments Act, 2006, and called for both proposals to be deferred until their impact on traffic, public access and emergency services is properly assessed.
The development comes just three days after Belagavi North MLA Asif (Raju) Sait raised the issue with the district administration, police and Cantonment authorities. At a meeting on August 14, Sait opposed the proposed closure of roads and approach routes used by the public, warning that thousands of citizens depend on these routes for their daily commute.
The MLA had urged officials to ensure that existing public roads were not closed without considering the impact on commuters and the wider traffic movement across the city.
The district administration has now formally put similar concerns on record, but with a detailed set of objections covering traffic capacity, public access, emergency response and the legal basis for the proposed restrictions.
DC Questions Road Swap and Traffic Barriers
The objections relate to CBR No. 26, concerning the proposed exchange of three Cantonment Fund Roads with one MES road, and CBR No. 27, concerning the installation of traffic barriers at two locations.
Under CBR No. 26, Albert Ekka Road from Raigarh Gate to Ginjee Gate, Smart Road from Harshan Enclave Gate to Ramghat Road, and Queen’s Garden Road from Sharquat Park to Queen’s Garden are proposed to be handed over to the Army/MES in exchange for Gymkhana Road between Shourya Chowk and Gandhi Chowk. Roshan has questioned whether one road can adequately compensate for the loss of three separate routes serving different corridors. He has sought a comprehensive traffic impact, connectivity and capacity assessment before any final decision is taken.
The DC has also objected to the proposed installation of traffic barriers near BC No. 183 on Independence Road and on Gymkhana Road near Gurudwara Gate. He has sought disclosure of the specific reasons and security grounds for the proposed barriers.
The letter notes that the affected roads are used by residents, schoolchildren, commuters, small traders and others for daily movement. It also points out that the roads form part of the district’s internal mobility network and are relied upon for ambulance movement, fire-tender access and access to public services during emergencies.
Click Here to Read: Objection letter Cantt Bd Belagavi_260817
Public Hearing and Defence Ministry Review Sought
Roshan has questioned the absence of a specific documented security threat in the two proposals. His letter states that Section 258(2) of the Cantonments Act permits permanent closure or restriction of access to a street only for security reasons and bars closure for other reasons.
The DC has therefore asked the Cantonment Board to place on record the specific security grounds, if any, supporting both proposals.
He has also sought a public hearing in addition to the written objections already invited, citing the scale of public interest in the matter. The Board has been asked to conduct and disclose a comprehensive traffic impact and alternative connectivity study before proceeding with CBR No. 26.
Roshan has further sought confirmation that the Ministry of Defence protocol on closure of roads in cantonments has been followed for both proposals and asked that the district administration’s objection, along with objections received from the public, be forwarded to the Ministry of Defence.
Most significantly, the Deputy Commissioner has asked the Cantonment Board to ensure that no final closure or barrier installation order is issued or implemented until the requested assessments and procedural steps are completed and communicated to the district administration.
The sequence of developments gives the issue added significance for Belagavi residents. Sait’s intervention on August 14 brought the potential impact of the proposed restrictions on daily commuters into focus. The district administration’s formal objection three days later has now placed those concerns on an official record and called for detailed scrutiny before the Cantonment Board proceeds.
For citizens, the immediate issue is whether existing routes through the Cantonment will remain accessible while the proposed road swap and barrier installations are examined. The DC’s letter makes clear that the district administration wants traffic, public access, emergency movement and the stated security rationale addressed before any final implementation.




















